In response to my tepid comments about the potential Middleboro Mega Bingo Hall, a regular reader sent the following:
Much more important, the Hawaii decision, which everyone is forgetting!! This decision puts the nail in the coffin for investers' Reservation Shopping, especially in New England.
The March, Carcieri v Salazar ruling from SCOTUS says that tribes not "now" federally recognized and under federal jurisdiction in 1934 are not eligible for federal trust under the IRA and created a limit to Secretary of Interior authority. There are about 562 tribes currently recognized but there were only 59 IRA tribes on the list. The potential impact is staggering.
Within weeks of the 8-1 Carcieri v Salazar decision, a second strike on fee to trust was issued. This time it came from a case originating in the state of Hawaii. In the 9-0 decision on Hawaii v. the Office of Hawaiian Affairs. Justice Alito wrote, "It would raise grave constitutional concerns" Congress sought to "cloud Hawaii's title to its sovereign lands" after it had joined the Union. "We have emphasized that Congress cannot, after statehood reserve or convey....lands that have already been bestowed upon a state". How many readers of this paper could be effected by issues concerning land that has been "bestowed upon a state"; as an original colony, through disestablished territory or when the territory entered into statehood?
The hat trick came from the Navajo Nation v. United States, Essentially, in this 9-0 decision SCOTUS ruled that it is necessary to have a statute or a regulation establishing trust.
Congressional hearings have been held and some of those in Congress believe that although they have tried there is no fix to the Carcieri decision. FEE TO TRUST IS IN TROUBLE.